Nobody could accuse Alan Milburn of thinking small. His final report on youth employment and education runs to 267 pages, with an executive summary that could feasibly pass for a full-length report in its own right. Much of it is necessarily wonky, packed with a dizzying array of proposals whose full policy implications will take time to unpick. But the sheer scale of the undertaking is telling: the review is proposing nothing less than a Rooseveltian ‘new deal for a new generation’.
Accordingly, the final report outlines a plan tracking a young person’s journey from the early years to the labour market, taking in the health, employment and welfare systems along the way. Education acts as its pivot point: what we put into the system, and where young people go when they leave it. Its organising principle is that the success of the education system should be judged not only on the qualifications young people achieve, but on where they go next and whether they stay there. Many across the sector have advocated for this shift in priorities for years.
Yet a blueprint of this scale inevitably opens as many questions as it answers, and in education, the unsettled detail matters as much as the ambition. Several proposals rest on measures that remain untested; others, as currently designed, could work against the young people they are meant to help. Five unanswered questions stand out: what does existing evidence tell us about each, and what must the government clarify before taking the proposals forward?
Five areas to watch
- Will the new measures show whether gaps are really closing?
- Should University Technical Colleges (UTCs) expand before their problems at 16 are fixed?
- What do pre-apprentices who don’t progress leave with?
- Can colleges grow by 150,000 in each year without the staff to teach them?
- Should college funding follow outcomes that colleges can only partly control?
1. Will the new measures show whether gaps are really closing?
The review asks the government to report annually on whether attainment gaps between socio-economic groups and across different areas are narrowing or widening, and to set out how it is deploying resources to close them. This is of course something we endorse. We know these gaps open before children start school and shape everything that follows, and regular reporting should, in theory, make it easier to hold government to account.
However, measures of these gaps are only meaningful if they reflect underlying changes in inequalities – and on that, the review is silent. Universal Credit protections have steadily expanded the group of children identified as disadvantaged in official measures, meaning the existing gap measures are less reliable for measuring change over time. The government should follow EPI’s lead in using a broader but more consistent group of disadvantaged children, to better reflect actual changes in inequalities over time.
The same caution applies to the review’s proposed ‘ready-for-work rate’, which would sit alongside Progress 8 and Attainment 8 from 2028 and carry, in characteristically Milburnian phrasing, ‘parity of esteem’ in Ofsted inspections. Developing an assessment of work readiness makes sense, but giving it that much weight in inspection presupposes answers to two basic questions: how can we reliably measure work readiness, and how much can schools influence such a measure? Decision-makers need to resolve both before establishing it as a potentially high-stakes accountability metric.
2. Should University Technical Colleges (UTCs) expand before their problems at 16 are fixed?
The review proposes expanding University Technical Colleges – of which there are currently 44 – and making the ‘UTC sleeve’ model inside mainstream schools ‘over time a mainstream part of the school landscape’. To support this, it cites evidence that UTC leavers are ‘more likely to enter apprenticeships and more likely to be employed’.
That evidence is sound, but it describes the students who stay the course. EPI’s own research on UTCs found high rates of departure at 16, alongside GCSE results below what students’ prior attainment would predict: over half of enrolled students leave the UTC at the end of Key Stage 4. Research from the Centre for Vocational Education Research (CVER), in turn, shows that entry age makes a decisive difference, with sharply diverging outcomes between those who join at the non-standard transition age of 14 and those who enter at 16 – the latter boosting ‘vocational achievement without harming academic achievement’. The recent research from Policy Exchange cited in the review suggests some improvements, but by no means resolves these concerns about UTCs.
Taken together, the evidence does not invalidate technical routes from age 14, but it calls into question whether 14-19 institutions are the best model for delivering on these pathways in a system that is built around transitions at 16. The review’s proposal to embed UTC provision within schools may help here, but the onus is on the government to show that expanded UTC provision will actually help address the NEET crisis.
3. What do pre-apprentices who don’t progress leave with?
The review proposes an initial 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places, combining English and maths, technical learning, work-readiness support and employer placements. Colleges would be the main providers for 16- to 18-year-olds, with level 1 provision and the new level 2 Occupational Certificates forming the programme’s basis. The report is clear that completion alone should not count as success: ‘A pre-apprenticeship should lead into an apprenticeship, skilled work or further technical study’.
Judging the programme on progression is right. Yet it leaves open what happens to the young people who do not complete the programme or progress to an apprenticeship. EPI’s research on the T Level transition programme found that preparatory courses work best when they offer a recognised qualification or credit in their own right. Only around 1 in 10 students on the transition programme moved on to T Levels, and around 1 in 4 of those who did dropped out within their first year. And as our research on school leaving ages across the UK shows, just keeping young people in education longer is not enough: what they achieve during that time matters.
Pre-apprenticeships therefore need recognised achievements built in. Those completing the programme should leave with a meaningful stand-alone qualification. Progression matters, but young people should also have something to show for the work they put in.
4. Can colleges grow by 150,000 in each year without the staff to teach them?
The review’s ambition for further education is its largest education proposal: over the next decade, more than 150,000 additional 18- to 24-year-olds participating in FE each year, closing the gap with countries such as the Netherlands, Denmark and Germany. The ambition is worth backing, but securing the college workforce to deliver this will be challenging.
Colleges already struggle to recruit and retain staff, particularly in the technical subjects the review wants to expand. The report’s solution is a ‘high-status industry-to-FE route’ featuring ‘structured initial preparation, high-quality mentoring, subject-specific pedagogy and sustained professional development’, building on the existing Taking Teaching Further programme. Those are sensible proposals, yet the review says little about pay – which sits at the heart of the recruitment crisis. Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) analysis found that while the median salary for a school teacher fell by 14% in real terms between 2010-11 and 2022-23, the median salary for a college lecturer fell by 19%. An expansion on this scale will require funding for places and a credible path towards pay parity with schools, alongside any new recruitment routes.
5. Should college funding follow outcomes that colleges can only partly control?
The review recommends moving FE funding away from a ‘simple activity-based model, where colleges are funded according to the number of places they provide, towards one that also recognises and rewards outcomes and destinations’. These outcome measures would be ‘adjusted to reflect different learner baselines, including disadvantage, care experience and SEND status’.
The aim is understandable, but the mechanism warrants scrutiny. While the proposed participation premium and the changes to in-year funding are designed to bring young people back into education, tying funding to destinations could undermine this – where young people end up after college depends on far more than the institution itself, including the local labour market, family circumstances and health. Research from CVER on college value added finds much larger differences between colleges in their contribution to qualification attainment than to subsequent employment. Adjusting for learner baselines is necessary, but the review does not show how much of that external variation its adjustments would remove. Until it can, observed destinations should not be treated as a clean proxy for college quality, still less used to determine core funding.
Across all five questions, the review is right about what should count: where young people go, and whether they stay, matters just as much as what they achieve. Measuring those things accurately and fairly, however, is harder than the review allows. Getting this wrong could hamper the life chances of the very young people any reforms are meant to reach.

